Is Presidium Gem Tester Accurate? A Comprehensive ReviewWhen it comes to buying or selling gemstones, accuracy in testing is crucial. One of the tools frequently used by jewelers and gem enthusiasts is the Presidium Gem Tester. This handheld device is designed to help identify gemstones by measuring their thermal conductivity. But the question on many minds is is the Presidium Gem Tester accurate? In this topic, we will explore how the Presidium Gem Tester works, its accuracy, and whether it is a reliable tool for gemstone identification.
What is the Presidium Gem Tester?
The Presidium Gem Tester is a portable, easy-to-use device that identifies gemstones based on their thermal conductivity. Different gemstones conduct heat at different rates, and this tool uses this property to distinguish between various types of stones. The tester works by touching the gem with a probe, which measures how quickly heat is conducted through the stone. The device then provides a reading on the scale, indicating which gemstone it likely is.
Presidium Gem Testers are popular among jewelers, gemologists, and hobbyists due to their compact size and user-friendly design. The device can test a wide range of gemstones, including diamonds, sapphires, rubies, and more.
How Does the Presidium Gem Tester Work?
The Presidium Gem Tester functions by utilizing a simple principle thermal conductivity. The tester measures how well a gemstone transfers heat. When you place a gemstone on the probe, the tool heats up the stone and measures how quickly the heat moves through it. Based on this rate, the tester identifies the stone.
Gemstones such as diamonds, which are known for their excellent thermal conductivity, will show faster heat transfer compared to other stones like cubic zirconia, which do not conduct heat as well. The tester provides a reading on the scale, indicating which gem you are dealing with.
The device is calibrated to identify common gemstones like
-
Diamonds
-
Sapphires
-
Rubies
-
Emeralds
-
Quartz
-
And more
Accuracy of the Presidium Gem Tester
While the Presidium Gem Tester is widely used and generally accurate, it does have some limitations. The accuracy of the device largely depends on the following factors
1. Gemstone Size and Shape
The size and shape of the gemstone can impact the tester’s readings. Very small stones or stones that are cut in unusual shapes may provide less accurate results. The tool works best with standard-sized gemstones that are cut in a shape that allows for good heat conductivity.
2. Surface Condition of the Gemstone
A dirty or poorly maintained gemstone can affect the accuracy of the test. Any dirt, oil, or residue on the surface of the stone can interfere with the heat transfer process. It’s important to clean gemstones before testing them to ensure the most accurate results.
3. Gemstone Coatings or Treatments
Some gemstones may have coatings or treatments that affect their thermal conductivity. For example, diamonds that have been treated or coated with a special layer might not test as accurately as untreated diamonds. In such cases, the Presidium Gem Tester may give a misleading result, especially if the gemstone has been treated to mimic the properties of another stone.
4. Temperature and Environmental Factors
External factors, such as room temperature and humidity, can also affect the performance of the tester. While the device is designed to work in various environments, extreme temperature differences may impact the results.
5. Synthetic Gemstones
The Presidium Gem Tester may struggle to differentiate between natural and synthetic gemstones, especially for stones that have the same thermal properties. While synthetic diamonds, for example, have the same thermal conductivity as natural diamonds, the tool will identify both as diamonds, making it less reliable for identifying synthetic vs. natural stones.
Pros and Cons of the Presidium Gem Tester
Pros
-
User-friendly The Presidium Gem Tester is easy to use, even for those who are not professional gemologists. The device provides quick results with minimal effort.
-
Portability It is compact and lightweight, making it ideal for use on the go. Jewelers can carry it to gem shows, during appraisals, or while buying gemstones.
-
Multiple Stone Identification The device can identify a wide range of gemstones, including diamonds, sapphires, emeralds, and more, making it versatile for gem enthusiasts and professionals alike.
-
Quick Results It delivers results within seconds, allowing jewelers to quickly identify stones without the need for complex or time-consuming tests.
Cons
-
Limited Differentiation for Similar Stones As mentioned, the device can struggle with differentiating between gemstones that have similar thermal conductivity, such as synthetic diamonds and natural diamonds.
-
Surface Condition Sensitivity The accuracy of the test can be compromised if the gemstone is not clean or has coatings.
-
Not a Substitute for Expert Analysis While the Presidium Gem Tester is a valuable tool for initial identification, it is not a substitute for more detailed testing by professional gemologists, especially for rare or unusual gemstones.
How to Improve Accuracy with the Presidium Gem Tester
To get the most accurate readings from the Presidium Gem Tester, consider the following tips
-
Clean Your Stones Before testing, make sure the gemstone is clean and free of oils, dirt, or any other residues that could interfere with the heat transfer.
-
Use the Correct Temperature Ensure that the room temperature is moderate, as extreme temperatures can affect the tester’s performance.
-
Test Multiple Times If you are unsure about the result, test the gemstone multiple times to confirm the reading. If you receive inconsistent results, it could be a sign that the stone is not reacting as expected.
-
Know the Limitations Remember that while the Presidium Gem Tester is useful for identifying common gemstones, it may not be as effective for identifying synthetics, treated stones, or unusual gems.
The Presidium Gem Tester is a valuable tool for anyone in the gem industry or for enthusiasts who want a quick way to identify gemstones. It is particularly useful for distinguishing between diamonds and other stones, as well as identifying sapphires, rubies, and other common gems. However, like any tool, it does have limitations, particularly when it comes to synthetic gemstones, treated stones, and extremely small or irregularly shaped stones.
For most users, the Presidium Gem Tester provides a good balance of affordability, ease of use, and accuracy. However, for more complex or high-stakes situations, such as appraisals or authenticity checks, it’s always advisable to consult a professional gemologist for a more thorough analysis.