A motion to compel answers to deposition questions is a legal request asking the court to require a witness or deponent to answer specific questions during a deposition. Depositions are a critical part of the discovery process, where attorneys gather information before trial. However, disputes may arise when a witness refuses to answer questions or an opposing counsel objects excessively. Understanding when and how to file a motion to compel can help ensure that relevant testimony is obtained.
What is a Motion to Compel Answers to Deposition Questions?
A motion to compel is a formal request to the court to enforce compliance with discovery rules. When a witness or opposing party refuses to answer relevant deposition questions, the attorney taking the deposition may file a motion to compel the court to intervene. Courts typically grant these motions if the requested information is:
-
Relevant to the case
-
Not privileged (e.g., attorney-client privilege)
-
Necessary for discovery
Filing a motion to compel can help prevent unnecessary delays and ensure that all parties comply with discovery obligations.
Common Reasons for Filing a Motion to Compel
There are several scenarios in which a motion to compel may be necessary:
1. Refusal to Answer Questions
A witness may refuse to answer questions, either by claiming ignorance or asserting a legal objection. If the refusal is unjustified, the party conducting the deposition can seek court intervention.
2. Excessive Objections from Opposing Counsel
Attorneys may object to questions for valid reasons (e.g., privilege, relevance). However, some lawyers use objections strategically to disrupt or delay depositions. If objections are excessive or unwarranted, a motion to compel can address the issue.
3. Instructions Not to Answer
In some cases, opposing counsel may instruct a witness not to answer a question. While this is appropriate in cases of privilege, it is improper when used to block relevant inquiries.
4. Evasive or Incomplete Responses
Even when a witness answers, they may be evasive, vague, or misleading. Courts often require clear, direct answers in depositions, making a motion to compel necessary.
5. Failure to Produce Documents for Deposition
If a deponent is required to bring specific documents but fails to do so, the party conducting the deposition may file a motion to compel document production along with deposition answers.
Legal Standards for a Motion to Compel
Courts evaluate motions to compel based on:
-
Relevance – Is the question related to claims or defenses in the case?
-
Privilege – Does the witness have a legal right to refuse to answer?
-
Proportionality – Is the request reasonable and necessary for discovery?
-
Obstruction – Has the opposing party acted in bad faith to delay proceedings?
Rules governing motions to compel vary by jurisdiction, but most courts follow the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) Rule 37, which outlines sanctions for failing to comply with discovery requests.
How to File a Motion to Compel Answers to Deposition Questions
Step 1: Attempt to Resolve the Dispute Informally
Before filing a motion to compel, most courts require attorneys to meet and confer in good faith to resolve the issue. This involves discussing the disputed questions with opposing counsel to reach a resolution.
Step 2: Draft the Motion
The motion should include:
-
Introduction: A brief summary of the deposition and the dispute.
-
Statement of Facts: A description of what happened, including specific questions that were not answered.
-
Legal Arguments: Citations to relevant laws, rules, and case precedents.
-
Request for Relief: A clear statement of what the court should order, such as compelling answers or imposing sanctions.
Step 3: Attach Supporting Evidence
Evidence may include:
-
Deposition transcript excerpts showing the refusal to answer.
-
Correspondence with opposing counsel attempting to resolve the issue.
-
Affidavits or declarations explaining why the questions are relevant.
Step 4: File the Motion with the Court
The motion must be filed in the correct court, following jurisdictional rules. Some courts require electronic filing, while others accept paper submissions.
Step 5: Attend the Hearing (If Required)
Courts may schedule a hearing to allow both parties to argue their positions. The moving party should be prepared to explain why the requested answers are necessary.
Possible Court Rulings on a Motion to Compel
The court may:
-
Grant the motion: Ordering the witness to answer the disputed questions.
-
Deny the motion: If the court finds the questions irrelevant or privileged.
-
Modify the request: Requiring answers to some questions but not others.
-
Issue sanctions: If a party acted in bad faith, the court may impose fines, fees, or even strike claims.
Potential Sanctions for Noncompliance
If a party refuses to comply with a court order compelling deposition answers, sanctions may include:
-
Monetary fines to cover legal fees.
-
Striking of pleadings if noncompliance affects case fairness.
-
Adverse inference instructions, where the jury is told to assume missing answers would have been unfavorable to the noncompliant party.
Best Practices to Avoid Motion to Compel Disputes
-
Ask clear, precise questions – Avoid overly broad or vague questions that invite objections.
-
Prepare for objections – Know when objections are valid and be ready to respond.
-
Document everything – Keep records of all communications regarding deposition disputes.
-
Use court rules strategically – Understanding local discovery rules can help avoid unnecessary motions.
A motion to compel answers to deposition questions is a powerful tool for ensuring that depositions are conducted fairly and that relevant information is disclosed. Courts generally favor open discovery, and parties who unjustifiably refuse to answer questions risk court sanctions. By understanding when and how to file a motion to compel, litigants can protect their rights and ensure a fair legal process.